The Asia Cup 2025 Super 4 clash between Pakistan and India turned controversial when Fakhar Zaman was declared out following a disputed catch. The decision quickly ignited debate, with several former players criticizing the third umpire’s judgment.
They argued that television replays were inconclusive, and in such cases, the benefit of the doubt should have gone to the batter.
Ex-cricketers pointed out that decisions like this can drastically shift the momentum of high-stakes encounters, particularly in India–Pakistan matches, where emotions and expectations run high.
Many expressed disappointment that technology, designed to ensure fairness and accuracy, once again left fans and analysts questioning the ruling instead of settling the debate.
